Bella Vita City Grill
430-16 North Country Road
St. James, NY 11780
631.862.8060


The Beautiful Life In St. James

Bella Vita City Grill is an exceptional restaurant that has been satisfying guests since December 1996. This fine eatery is located on North Country Road in Saint James at the Colonial Shopping Center.  

Bella Vita City Grill is a family operated and chef-owned restaurant.  Executive Chef Anthony Cambria Jr. and Anthony Cambria Sr. built the restaurant together from the ground up.  The Italian translation of “Bella Vita” is “a beautiful life,” but to the Cambria Family it has a much deeper meaning.  Anthony Cambria Jr.’s grandmother was named Vita Marie.  Vita immigrated to America, and made her kitchen the heart of her home.  Anthony has dedicated the restaurant to serving creative Italian-American cuisine.  The New York Restaurant Association awarded Anthony Jr. with the Long Island Restaurateur of the Year in 2002.  

 

The interior of the restaurant has a comfortable and familiar feel to as you immediately enter.  The bar is directly in front of you upon entrance with a trendy sign reading Bella Vita City Grill.  As you walk past the bar area, you are lead by a half wall towards the right which leads into one of two dining rooms.  The windows are adorned with green and white curtains decorated with miniature lights above.  Candles set the mood at each table.  The artwork in the dining room pays homage to famous eateries of New York City – Paddy’s Clam House (one of the largest and oldest seafood establishments in New York), Carnegie Deli, and Alleva (oldest Italian cheese store in New York).

A majority of the original staff from 1996 is still providing outstanding service at Bella Vita City Grill.  Every staff member encountered by our group that evening was courteous and friendly.  Our waitress, like most of the employees, was knowledgeable not only of the items on the menu, but about the restaurant’s history and the Cambria family.

Fresh white bread and slices of crispy baked garlic bread are set out in a silver spiral metal basket. (below left)  The garlic bread was a different approach to the traditional preparation.  It was crispy and zesty.

Our first salad was the “The Famous” House Chopped Salad (above right).  It combined fresh roasted peppers, grilled artichokes, black olives, sundried tomatoes, pecorino romano, pine nuts, chopped mesclun and sweet balsamic vinaigrette.  Patrons have the option of adding grilled chicken, grilled shrimp, tuna, or seared salmon for an additional charge to this or any salad.  The dressing added a unique sweetness to the salad and paired well with the buttery sweet taste of the pine nuts.  The Chopped Salad was extremely flavorful.

The second salad was quite an attention grabber.  The Bella Vita “Martini Salad” (above) is served tossed inside a whimsically large martini shaker and strained into an oversized martini glass, which creates an amazing presentation.  As mentioned, by both Anthony and our waitress, some customers have ordered this salad because they saw it at another table.  Inside the martini shaker are macadamia nuts, dried cranberries, baby arugula, field greens, and granny smith apples in Chopin vodka citrus vinaigrette.  On a skewer in the martini dish are bleu cheese stuffed olives and cherry tomatoes.  The macadamia nuts were a huge hit with all of us.  The dressing was light and perfectly proportioned to the amount of salad.  This salad is highly recommended for those that prefer it shaken, not stirred.

The first appetizer enjoyed by our table was the Bresaola (above left); a plate of thinly sliced cured beef, arugula, pine nuts, hearts of palm, shaved grana padano cheese, and truffle oil.  The paper thin slices of imported beef were strategically arranged around the hearts of palm and shaved grana padano cheese.  This dish was one of the many creative options offered by Bella Vita.  Each bite was quite flavorful with a nice salty finish from the cured meat.  Next we were served the Australian Lamb Lollipops (above right).  The two lamb chops were pan seared, topped with oreganata breadcrumbs, and laid against a pile of potato hay.  A delicious aroma emanated from this appetizer.  The lamb was tender and seasoned to perfection.  The crispy and crunchy bed of potato hay assisted with the presentation. 

Our last appetizer, Crispy Fried Calamari, Kung Pao Style (above) was tossed with scallions, peanuts, sesame seeds in an orange ginger soy glaze.  There was plenty on the plate to share among the group.  The orange ginger soy glaze provided a sweet and tangy finish to each and every bite.  The tender calamari was lightly battered and prepared perfectly. The scallions added a nice flare to this treat. 

Our first entrée ended up being the table’s absolute favorite – Spiced Pumpkin Ravioli (below left).  A generous portion of ravioli with roasted pecans was covered in a Frangelico cream sauce and topped with sweet potato hay.  Although it is considered an autumn dish, it appears on the menu throughout the year.  Each forkful was rich, creamy and delicious.  As the table remarked on the unique sweetness of the dish, Anthony informed us that this dish is sometimes ordered as a dessert.  We moved onto an entirely different pasta option on the menu, Fresh Cheese Agnolotti (below right).  This dish had cheese filled half moon pasta, sautéed lobster meat and shrimp in a light lobster cream sauce.  The creamy sauce was rich and satisfying, and the seafood was tender.  The Fresh Cheese Agnolotti is a light and flavorful option.

Bella Vita’s Veal Chop (below left) can be grilled to your liking and finished “steakhouse” style with sea salt and butter.  The side of broccoli rabe was sautéed in oil and garlic.  Both components of the plate were outstanding.  The buttery veal chop was juicy and tender while the meat melted in our mouths.  Our evening was finished with the Half Roasted “Maple Leaf Farm” Duck (below right) presented alongside crisp sweet potato gnocchi, seasonal vegetables, and wild berry demi.  A strong sweet aroma was given off by this entrée.  It was an excellent culinary presentation of duck.  The duck was moist and well seasoned.  Crispy sweet potato gnocchi was an interesting side, as it was fresh and house made.  It would be an excellent option for those in the mood for duck.

The first dessert sampled was The Famous Chocolate Bag (below left).  Hidden beyond a thin veil of dark chocolate shaped to resemble a miniature paper bag was white chocolate mousse and fresh berries.  The berries were farm fresh as if hand picked the same day.  The chocolate bag appeared neat and tidy on the plate when it arrived, but after “ripping” it open, the contents did not remain on the plate long.  The next delicious dessert was the Wild Maine Blueberry Pie (below right).  Fresh baked and served with vanilla gelato and fresh cream on a plate decorated with confectionary sugar and raspberry sauce.  Once again the freshness of the berries was unbelievable.  The pie was crusty and warm.  



The third and last dessert was The Dream (below).  Definitely a dessert imagined in someone’s dream; a Nougatine wafer filled with vanilla gelato was dipped in Belgium chocolate and served over fresh raspberry sauce.  It was the embodiment of a perfectly sweet dream.  While there was no more room for sampling any others, the variety of gelato on the dessert menu caught our attention – malted milk ball, vanilla, cinnamon, espresso, pistachio, and moose tracks.

The variety of options created too many favorites to recommend only one particular dish.  Our recommendation would be to go with a large group and everyone order a different dish.  The options on the menu are not only creative and unique but completely satisfying.  There were no disappointments at our table.  The items on Bella Vita City Grill’s menu reflect the fusion of Italian traditions and eclectic American cuisine.  It is Anthony’s hope for Vita Marie’s spirit and joy of cooking to continue to live each day through the culinary splendor that has been created at Bella Vita City Grill.  As we see it, the excellent service and the incredible cuisine offered should easily keep Anthony’s vision alive.

Overall RatingExcellent

Cuisine: Italian-American Fusion

Ambiance & Décor:  Classy & Comfortable

Prices: Lunch $7-$29, Dinner $15-$29

Website: Bella Vita City Grill


© All Rights Reserved Expo Sure USA Inc.    Trademarks are the property of their respective companies.